Recent trends and developments in Northern Europe suggest the shift away from cash and toward purely digital payment systems may have reached its limits \u2014 at least for now.<\/p>\n
In a major U-turn in the Global War on Cash, the government and central bank of Norway, one of Europe\u2019s most cashless economies, are seeking to slow or even reverse the mass abandonment of cash. Only 3% of Norwegians used cash in their latest purchase in a physical shop, according to a recent central bank survey.<\/p>\n
In a bid to change that, a new amendment to Norway\u2019s Financial Contracts Act came into force on October 1 that bolsters citizens\u2019 rights to pay with cash in retail settings. The new legislation should sound the death knell for all the \u201cwe only accept cards\u201d signs plastered on shop windows throughout the country, reports the Norwegian online newspaper Nettavisen.<\/p>\n
Norway\u2019s central bank, Norges Bank, explains on its website how the new amendment will \u201cclarify\u201d customers\u2019 right to pay in cash:<\/p>\n
Section 3-5 (1) of the Central Bank Act stipulates that banknotes and coins issued by Norges Bank are legal tender. It further states that no one is obliged to accept more than 25 coins of each denomination in one transaction. Beyond this, the Act does not elaborate on what legal tender implies.<\/p>\n
In June 2024, the Storting enacted an amendment to Section 2-1, third paragraph of the Financial Contracts Act, clarifying consumers\u2019 right to pay with cash:<\/p>\n
\u201cIn sales premises where a business regularly sells goods or services to consumers, the consumer shall be offered the option to pay with legal tender if it is possible to pay for the goods or services with other payment solutions in or in immediate connection to the sales premises. If the business has available change, it must also offer to provide change in connection with the payment, unless there is a clear discrepancy between the banknote offered as payment and the amount to be paid. The first and second sentences do not apply to the sale of goods from vending machines, sales in unstaffed premises, and sales in premises to which only a limited group of people have access. The first and second sentences also do not apply when the amount to be paid exceeds 20,000 kroner.\u201d[1]<\/p>\n
For anyone wondering, 20,000 kroner is worth close to $2,000. As Norge Bank explains, retail businesses that refuse to abide by this change in the law could face financial penalties:<\/p>\n
In connection with this legislative amendment, the Storting also decided to introduce a sanction in the form of an administrative fine, which may be imposed if businesses willfully or negligently violate the rules in Section 2-1, third paragraph.<\/p>\n
Motive #1: Genuine Financial Inclusion<\/p>\n
One of the main justifications for the legislation is to support the estimated 600,000 people in the country \u2014 equivalent to roughly 10% of the population \u2014 who struggle to use digital payments, and who have been increasingly excluded from the retail economy. Cashless economics is often touted as a means of encouraging financial inclusion, which generally means extending exploitative and abusive financial services to those previously excluded. However, in reality there is no more inclusive form of payment method than cash.<\/p>\n
\u201cIn a digital world, it can be easy to forget that there is a large group of people who are not digital,\u201d says Minister of Justice and Public Security Emilie Enger Mehl. \u201cCash is also an important emergency preparedness for society. I am pleased that the majority in the Storting [Norway\u2019s parliament] so clearly supported our proposal to strengthen the right to pay with cash. The regulations have been too unclear. People should be confident that they will be able to pay when they go to the store, to a restaurant or to the hairdresser.\u201d<\/p>\n
Many Norweigan pensioners are \u201cjubilant\u201d about the change in law, reports Nettavisen.<\/p>\n
\u201cThis is very important for all the elderly who struggle to pay online, remember the code or who struggle to trust bank cards,\u201d says manager Jan Davidsen, manager of the Norwegian Pensioners\u2019 Association. \u201cFor many, cash provides security, it is something they have become accustomed to over the course of a long life. This has been a battle for us, so now we are going to celebrate!\u201d<\/p>\n
But not everyone is cracking out the champagne.<\/p>\n
\u201cI\u2019m not going to change my practices,\u201d Anders Ellburg, general manager of Holmenkollen, an upmarket restaurant in Helsinki, tells Finans Fokus:<\/p>\n
\u201cCash costs me a lot of money to handle. I run a clean business. Only those who run the black market are interested in cash.<\/p>\n
Ellburg put his foot down against cash payment as early as 2014. The card advocate from the capital\u2019s fashionable restaurant scene is the only one of the cash-free players we have contacted who wanted to have a chat with Finansfokus. But Ellburg also made it clear that we should rather talk to those who still use cash \u2013 and ask why on earth they do it.<\/p>\n
\u201cI was the first in Norway to issue a press release stating that I do not accept cash. When older people have come and told me that they have been to the ATM to withdraw money, I have explained that there is no difference between entering the code in the ATM and entering it at a bank terminal in the restaurant,\u201d he says.<\/p>\n
Motive #2: Financial Resilience<\/p>\n
Besides ensuring that people are not excluded from participating in the economy, the new amendment has another important goal: to provide the economy with greater financial resiliency. In April, a press release from the Ministry of Justice and Public Security highlighted the importance of cash as an \u201calways on\u201d payment option, ensuring Norway\u2019s economy will not be rendered completely inaccessible in the event of \u201cprolonged power outages, system failure or digital attacks against payment systems and banks\u201d.<\/p>\n
The Norwegian Directorate for Civil Protection even recommends people to have some amounts of cash at all times in case digital forms of payment stop working \u2014 something that appears to be happening with increasing frequency. This echoes a similar message issued a couple of years ago by a Finnish central bank official. In October 2022, P\u00e4ivi Heikkinen, the Head of the Payment Systems Department and Chief Cashier at the Bank of Finland warned that households in Finland should make sure they have some cash on hand, just in case the country\u2019s payments system goes down.<\/p>\n
\u201cMore payment methods bring resilience,\u201d said Heikkinen. \u201cIf a single payment method sometimes does not work, then we have other payment methods at our disposal. Cash still plays a very important role here.\u201d<\/p>\n
A Growing Trend<\/p>\n
In another neck of the Scandinavian woods, the world\u2019s oldest central bank, Sweden\u2019s Riksbank, keeps sounding the alarm about the fragility of cashless economies, as we reported in May:<\/p>\n
Digitalization\u2026 makes payments \u201cmore vulnerable to cyber attacks and disruptions to the power grid and data communication,\u201d the bank points out. At the same time, the geopolitical developments of the past few years required \u201cSweden to have strong civil defense.\u201d The developments suggested \u201cthat we should concentrate more than before on the challenges of digitalization.\u201d<\/p>\n
Put another way, cash does not crash. It does not fail in a power cut or seize up during a cyber attack (though, of course, ATMs might). By contrast, digital payment systems need a stable and continuous internet connection to process transactions. When these connections fail, the result is often chaos. Digital payment outages have caused significant disruption in a host of countries in recent years, including the US,\u00a0the UK,\u00a0Australia,\u00a0Indonesia,\u00a0Germany,\u00a0Canada,\u00a0Spain\u00a0and\u00a0Norway. Generally speaking, the more cashless the country, the greater the disruption.<\/p>\n
Since that post went up, the world has suffered an even more disruptive payments outage. In July, a content update by the cyber-security firm CrowdStrike caused millions of Microsoft systems around the world to crash, bringing the operating systems of banks, payment card firms, airlines, hospitals, NHS clinics, retailers and hospitality businesses to a standstill. Businesse were faced with a stark choice: go cash-only, or close until the systems came back online.<\/p>\n
Such was the scale of the resulting disruption that even stalwart British media outlets like The Sun, The Times, The Guardian and The Mail ran articles on how the global IT outage had underscored the fragility of a cashless society. The Daily Mail\u00a0plastered the message across its front page:<\/p>\n
![\"Imagen\"](\"https:\/\/pbs.twimg.com\/media\/GS7VIz2W0AAAyOd?format=png&name=small\")
The digital payment outages didn\u2019t stop there; they just keep on coming. On September 12, 250,000 card terminals in Germany \u2014 the equivalent of one-in-four of the country\u2019s devices \u2014 stopped working, according to FAZ. Once again, the cause of the outage appears to be a software glitch, this time affecting the payment service provider Telecash. On the same day, outages were\u00a0also reported in the Netherlands.<\/p>\n
Protecting the Right to Use Cash: A Growing European Trend<\/p>\n
In recent years a growing number of countries in Europe have passed or proposed legislation to protect the right of citizens to use cash as payment. They include Switzerland and Austria, two countries where cash is still very much King, as well as Slovakia, where the Robert Fico government last year passed an amendment to the constitution intended to protect physical payments from a future in which the digital euro becomes mandatory.<\/p>\n
Back in Sweden, which is arguably even more cashless than Norway, the Riksbank, like its Norwegian counterpart, has called on the government to adopt urgent measures to strengthen cash\u2019s role as a means of payment. Late last year, the central bank echoed a point we have been making for the past few years: \u201cit is not enough to simply take measures to strengthen the availability of cash through withdrawal requirements and new depots, it must also be usable.\u201d<\/p>\n
That means taking a leaf out of neighbouring Norway\u2019s book and adopting legislation that makes it much harder for retail outlets to reject cash payments. In a 14-page response to a parliamentary inquiry on the State\u2019s role in payments, the Riksbank warned that \u201clegislation on cash needs to be tightened up immediately\u201d and \u201cpolitical decisions are needed urgently so that everyone can pay\u201d:<\/p>\n
\u201cCash is essential for digitally and financially excluded consumers. Cash is also the only payment instrument that can be used independently of electricity and telecommunications and is therefore important for Sweden\u2019s emergency preparedness. There is no reason or time to wait for a new review, as the Inquiry infers. There is a considerable risk that cash will be further marginalised and that in the near future it can no longer be used for essential purchases. The Riksbank therefore proposes legislative amendments regarding the possibility of paying cash for essential goods and an obligation for banks to accept cash deposits from consumers\u201d\u2026<\/p>\n
The Riksbank does not share the Inquiry\u2019s assessment that, with regard to legal tender, the
legislator can wait to introduce even stronger obligations to accept cash until a new review of
the status of cash and access to cash has been carried out. In the Riksbank\u2019s opinion, the Inquiry should have submitted legislative proposals that strengthen the position of cash even
more.<\/p>\n
The inquiry itself concluded that Sweden\u2019s shift toward a cashless society may have finally reached the outer limits of what is possible \u2014 at least for the \u201cforeseeable future.\u201d<\/p>\n
\u201cThe use of cash for payment purposes has gradually declined over a longer period of time and is now comparatively low,\u201d the inquiry reported, before adding that demand for cash has \u2018remained virtually unchanged\u2019 over the past five years. \u201cAnalysts have concluded that the direction of travel is clearly towards (in principle) a cashless society, especially in Sweden. The statistics, however, do not point to such a development, or indeed\u2026 that this will occur in the foreseeable future.\u201d<\/p>\n
Now, the central banks of both Sweden and Norway have the unenviable task of trying to slow or even reverse the mass abandonment of cash that they themselves helped set in motion. They will have their work cut out given that so much of their respective countries\u2019 cash infrastructure \u2014 in particular private banks\u2019 branch networks, ATMs and the distribution services offered by cash handling companies \u2014 has been allowed to wither over recent years.<\/p>\n
It also remains to be seen whether enough Swedish and Norwegian citizens are prepared to reembrace cash if it is made more available and easier to use. As in many countries, demand for cash in Norway has risen slightly over the past year with the number of withdrawals at ATMs ticking up, according to Norges Bank. But is this a sustainable trend? As payment technologies have advanced this century, most Norwegian and Swedish citizens have embraced the speed, ease and convenience of digital payments. But they were also nudged in that direction.<\/p>\n
By 2016, Sweden\u2019s commercial banks had made 60% of their branches cashless, as a 2019 Riksbank working paper documents. This made it much more difficult for citizens to access cash and for businesses to deposit it, which in turn accelerated the uptake of digital payments and the abandonment of cash. The Riksbank did its part by withdrawing many of Sweden\u2019s large denomination notes from circulation. Now, it is trying to halt, or at least slow, the country\u2019s onward march toward a cashless future.<\/p>\n
Time is of the essence. As the central bank warns, if urgent action isn\u2019t taken to fortify Sweden\u2019s cash infrastructure, it will soon be too late:<\/p>\n
[T]here are already such problems with cash and cash handling that there is reason to immediately tighten legislation to safe guard the position of cash and access to cash services. If the state waits until cash and cash services are further phased out, this could lead to a situation where it is too late to take action, or there is a risk that operators will be forced to go back and reinvest in equipment and systems.<\/p>\n
Given Norway and Sweden have gone further than most countries in removing cash from the economy, the fact they are both now warning about the dangers and vulnerabilities of a fully cashless economy as well as the urgent need to protect both access to and use of cash should be taken very seriously \u2014 not just within their borders but far beyond them.<\/p>\n
![\"Print](\"https:\/\/cdn.printfriendly.com\/buttons\/print-button-gray.png\")
<\/div>\n<\/div>\n